Yarn substitution: how to swap the yarn a pattern calls for
How to substitute yarn in a knitting or crochet pattern: match the weight and gauge, think about fibre, and work out how many balls you need by length.
· 6 min read

Yarn substitution means using a different yarn from the one a pattern names. Four things decide whether it works. Pick a yarn in the same weight category and check that you can match the pattern’s gauge with it. Choose a fibre that behaves in a similar way. Then buy by length (yards or metres), never by the number of balls or grams.
Here is each step, with a worked example for the part where swaps often run short: how many balls to buy.
Step 1: match the weight category
Start with the yarn the pattern names and find its weight. Most patterns print it in the materials list:
Yarn: 6 balls of DK weight wool (120 m / 131 yds per 50 g)
If the pattern only gives a brand and name, look the yarn up on the maker’s site or label. The Craft Yarn Council sorts yarns into eight categories, from 0 (lace) to 7 (jumbo), and many labels print that number in a small yarn-ball symbol. Your substitute should sit in the same category.
The names change between countries, which trips up a lot of swaps:
| Craft Yarn Council | US names | UK / Australian names |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Super fine | sock, fingering | 4 ply |
| 2 Fine | sport | 5 ply |
| 3 Light | DK, light worsted | DK, 8 ply |
| 4 Medium | worsted, aran | aran, 10 ply |
| 5 Bulky | chunky | chunky, 12 ply |
The full table, with gauge ranges and tool sizes for every category, is on our yarn weight chart.
One thing to know about “ply”: in UK and Australian names, it describes thickness. A yarn sold as 4 ply can be made of two strands or six.
Step 2: match the gauge
The weight category gets you close. Gauge (called tension in UK patterns) is what makes the size right. Patterns print it like this:
Gauge: 22 sts and 30 rows = 4 in (10 cm) in st st on 4 mm needles
Tension: 15 sts and 9 rows = 10 cm (4 in) over tr, using a 5 mm hook
That second line is a UK crochet pattern, so “tr” means a UK treble, which is a US double crochet.
Two yarns in the same category can still knit up at different gauges. The Craft Yarn Council’s range for light (DK) yarn in knitting is 21 to 24 stitches over 4 in, which is a wide spread on a sweater. Before you buy, compare the gauge printed on the new yarn’s label with the pattern’s. If they are close, buy one ball and make a swatch:
- Use the needle or hook size the pattern suggests. If you need a reminder of the conversions, the knitting needle size chart and crochet hook size chart have them.
- Work a square at least 6 in (15 cm) wide in the stitch the gauge line names. If the pattern is worked in the round, swatch in the round too, because many people knit a little differently on purl rows.
- Wash and dry it the way you will treat the finished piece. Many yarns relax or tighten after a wash.
- Measure across the middle, away from the edges, and count the stitches in 4 in (10 cm).
Too many stitches means your fabric is tighter than the pattern’s: go up a needle or hook size. Too few means it is looser: go down a size. Swatch again until the stitch count matches. Row gauge matters less on most patterns, because they often say “work until piece measures 30 cm” rather than giving a row count. It matters a lot where a pattern counts rows for shaping, such as a raglan or a top-down yoke. If your stitch gauge matches but your rows come out taller or shorter, keep the stitch gauge and adjust by measuring: work to the length the pattern gives, and recalculate any shaping spaced over a row count.
If you cannot get stitch gauge with any reasonable tool size, the yarn is the wrong weight for this pattern. Pick a different one.
Step 3: think about the fibre
Two yarns can share a weight and a gauge and still make very different fabric. The fibre changes how the piece hangs and holds its shape.
- Wool has memory: ribbing pulls back in, and the fabric holds its shape after washing. Superwash wool can grow a little when wet, so check your swatch after washing.
- Cotton and linen have almost no stretch. Ribbing stays flat and the fabric is heavier, so a sweater can drop longer than the pattern says. They show uneven stitches more than wool does.
- Acrylic is light and easy to wash. It holds its shape well but doesn’t block as well as wool.
- Alpaca and silk drape well, and alpaca is warm. Both are heavy for their thickness and tend to stretch over time.
The safest swap is the same fibre or a similar blend. If you change fibre, think about what the pattern relies on. A fitted rib cuff wants wool’s bounce, and a flowing summer top wants drape. A blanket or a toy will forgive almost anything.
Step 4: work out how much yarn by length
Grams don’t tell you how much yarn you have, because a dense cotton and a light wool of the same weight category can have very different lengths in a 50 g ball. Always compare yards or metres.
Take the pattern line from step 1:
Yarn: 6 balls of DK weight wool (120 m / 131 yds per 50 g)
- Find the total length the pattern needs: 6 balls × 120 m = 720 m.
- Check the length per ball of your substitute. Say it is 100 m per 50 g.
- Divide: 720 m ÷ 100 m = 7.2 balls.
- Round up. You need 8 balls.
If you change the size you make, take the number of balls for your size from the materials list. Many patterns give a list of amounts in brackets, one per size, and how to read size brackets shows how to find your number.
If your substitute is labelled in yards and the pattern in metres, convert one of them first: 1 yard is 0.9144 m, and 1 m is about 1.09 yards. For a garment, buy one extra ball. Your swatch uses some yarn, and a ball from the same dye lot is hard to find later.
In the Yarnstep app, you can add the yarn you own to your stash, and the enough yarn check compares the amount printed for your size with what you have.
Step 5: check the dye lot and the colour
Buy every ball you need at once, and check that the dye lot number on each label matches. Two lots of the same colour can differ enough to show as a stripe across a sweater. If the pattern uses colourwork, check that your substitute colours have enough contrast. Taking a black-and-white photo of the balls side by side shows whether two shades will blur together.
When the pattern names a yarn that no longer exists
Patterns outlive their yarns. When a discontinued yarn is named, you still have what you need. The weight and the length per ball, and usually the fibre, are printed in the materials list or can be found on old shop pages. Use those three, then follow the steps above. A designer’s original yarn is a good guide to the look they wanted, so stay close to its fibre if you can.
Questions people ask
Can I substitute a yarn of a different weight?
Only if you change the pattern too. A thicker or thinner yarn gives a different gauge, so the same stitch counts make a bigger or smaller piece. For a first swap, stay in the same weight category.
Can I use two strands of a thinner yarn instead of one thicker yarn?
Often, yes. Two strands of a fingering yarn held together usually land near DK or worsted, but the result varies by yarn. Knit or crochet a swatch with both strands and measure it before you commit.
Should I buy yarn by weight in grams or by length?
By length. Two 50 g balls can hold very different amounts of yarn, so compare yards or metres per ball and work out the total from the length the pattern needs.
Why does my swatch match but the finished piece is a different size?
The swatch was probably measured before washing, or was too small to measure well. Wash and dry it the way you will treat the finished piece, then measure across the middle of a swatch at least 6 in (15 cm) wide.


